My mom is Presbyterian and my dad is Catholic. My brothers, sister and I were all raised Catholic. We participated in
CCD classes (Catholic religion classes for kids who go to public instead of parochial school). We've all been baptised, had our first communion and confirmed as Catholics. I even taught the three year old Sunday School class at my church from 8
th through 12
th grade. Our family wasn't exactly devout though. We went to church sporadically and usually only for holidays like Christmas and Easter. For awhile, I made a real effort to be a good Catholic. But a few things got in the way.
Perhaps my first real beef with my religion came when I realized that as a Catholic, I was supposed to believe that my mom and most of her family would at best end up in purgatory for not being Catholic. I know very few people who are nicer than my mother and I can't imagine my mother's afterlife being anywhere other than heaven. Not to mention, why would God split up a family over religion? If we're all basically good people, shouldn't we all go to heaven and be together?
My second problem was in high school when I realized how serious confirmation was. I was confirmed at the age of 12 and didn't completely understand the commitment I was making to the church. I just thought it meant we were coming of age in the church but didn't really understand the meaning. Now I feel that I was tricked into confirmation but adults who should have known better.
Crys and I have talked about joining a church together. Clearly
Catholicism won't work if we want to be recognized as a family. But I am completely incapable of leaving the church. Mostly because I've been confirmed.
And my third major problem is the church's stance on GLBT issues. "Love the sinner, hate the sin". That just doesn't work for me. If I become a
devout Catholic, I have to deny my relationship. I certainly won't lie about who I am or how I live my life just to be a member of my church. Is that something God would want?
Crys would not be welcome as my partner. Our child would only be welcome as my child. That's not something I'm willing to live with. We are and will be a family, any church we belong to can take all of us or none of us.
This week I attended a Catholic funeral. Before we went, I had a decision to make. A decision I've been struggling with for several years and now seemed like the time to make it. Should I continue to participate in Catholic mass or should I deny that part of who I am? Catholic mass is full of ritual that only Catholics are obligated to adhere to.
Communion and kneeling being the two most
noticeable elements that set the
congregation apart from other religions. In the end, I decided that while I will never be able to fully join another religion, I will never be a practicing catholic again. I will never go to confession because that would mean confessing the sin of living with and loving my partner and therefore, I will never be able to take communion again. From now on, if I find myself at a Catholic mass, I won't genuflect before entering the pew or kneel in prayer like I've done so many times in past.
I joke about being a recovering Catholic and frequently question the
existence of God, but some days I long for the faith that comes to many people so easily. I miss the days when I believed that I could be a lesbian and a practicing Catholic. But now I know better and now I am stuck. Unable to participate in my religion and incapable of finding a new one.